Montreal Forum: Changes in Social Fabric of
Japan
Merle Aiko Okawara (Chairperson, JC
COMSA)
Presentation at GLOCOM-UQAM Forum, Montreal, Canada -
November 24, 2003
Winds of change have been blowing through the social
fabric of Japanese society, and today I would like to
explore a few of them with you. They are (1) the
decreasing number of children; (2) the aging population;
(3) the increasing participation of women in society,
and (4) the changing and diversifying lifestyles of
citizens.
Undoubtedly the most significant social change is the
result of lower fertility rates and people living
longer, giving rise to a rapid demographic transition
from a relatively young country until the 1950s (with an
average age of late twenties) to an aging society as
defined by the United Nations with an average age of
over 40 today.
In the 1940s women had an average of four children.
That figure has dropped dramatically in 2002 to 1.32.
According to the National Institute of Population and
Social Security Research, the Japanese population will
peak in 2007 and is projected to decline to 67 million
in 2100. That is a 50% decrease in a century, so you can
imagine what will happen if the population keeps
decreasing by 50% every 100 years. People joke that at
that rate, sometime in the next millennium the entire
population of Japan will be able to fit into Tokyo
dome.
But it is not a joking matter. This is a serious
problem that is being faced not only by Japan but also
by most developing countries, because a decreasing
population obviously will impede economic growth and put
pressures on the working population with regards to
social security.
Factors Related to Lower Birth Rates I
would like to just briefly go over the factors leading
to a decrease in the number of children. One of the
reasons for the drop in the fertility rate is that both
women and men are putting off marriage until a later
age, 29 for men and 27 for women. About half of women in
their late twenties, which is the age group that used to
have the highest birth rate, remains unmarried. Indeed,
when I was a younger a woman over 25 was referred to as
Christmas cake, because after the 25th of December
nobody is interested in Christmas cake. Women are
putting off marriage until a later age because they have
been brought up in a fairly affluent style by their
parents during the bubble years and don't feel that
young men could give them the same lifestyle. Also,
having children would place heavy economic burdens on
the young couple because housing and education costs are
so high.
The second reason for married women having fewer
children is the fact that more women would like to
continue working but find it difficult to do so with
children. This is due to inflexible customs and ideas
about gender roles by which men should work outside and
women should take care of the family. The Confucian
belief in "good wife, wise mother" still prevails to a
certain extent today.
Older and Living Longer The second major
social trend contributing to the present crises is a
rapidly graying society. Due to better health care and
improved standards of living, the life expectancy for
Japanese men is 78 and for women 85, the highest levels
in the world. In the year 2000 people over 65
represented 17% of the population, and this number is
expected to explode in the year 2050 to 36%. These two
social trends, lower fertility rates and a rapidly
graying population pose and will continue to pose
economic and political problems for Quebec and Japan and
for most developed countries.
Socio-Economic Impacts The major problems
resulting from lower fertility rates and an aging
population put pressures on the entire social security
system, including public pension, medical care and other
social welfare programs. The Ministry of Health, Labor
and Welfare is proposing that pension premiums be
revised from the current 13.5% to 20% of the annual
income of salaried workers by the year 2020. Since the
premiums are evenly shared by employee and employer,
there have been cries of resistance from both groups.
Most young people feel that in their retirement they
will never be able to receive benefits equivalent to
their contributions.
Possible Solutions There are several
possible solutions to this problem. The first option
would be to open our borders to immigration in the model
of Canada and the US to rejuvenate the population and
ease the burden on the working generation. Immigration
is a difficult issue and ways to tackle it have not
gained consensus among citizens.
During the years of high economic growth when there
was a severe labor shortage in Japan, the government
decided to allow limited immigration. Second and third
generation Japanese--descendants of Japanese emigrants
to South America--were allowed to enter Japan on work
visas. Indeed, my company was among those companies only
too happy to welcome these people to work in our
factories. Even today we have employees by the names of
Jose Suzuki and Gabriella Tanaka. Unfortunately these
South American returnees to Japan were among the first
to be let go in the recession and many are suffering not
only economically but also socially because they have
not yet been completely assimilated into society even
after ten or twenty years. Therefore, I think that the
idea of accepting other Asian immigrants on a large
scale is one that still will not be accepted by the
general public in the near future, although it is
certainly something that has to be carefully considered
for the long term.
The second solution would be to extend the retirement
age from 60 to 65.
Finally, the third solution would be to encourage
women to have more children by improving the social
infrastructure, increasing benefits and encouraging
corporations to introduce more flexible working
conditions. Although at present the unemployment rate is
at a high of about 5.3%, in the long run there is no
doubt that we will have a labor shortage. So the
government has to find ways of encouraging women to work
and at the same time to have more children, a difficult
task indeed.
Women in the Workplace There is a third
major social trend affecting present conditions, and
that is the growing impact made by women in the work
place and in society in general.
A little over 50% of women are continuing on to two
year colleges and universities, slightly more than men.
This is preparing many women for jobs in corporate,
legal, medical and other sectors.
But the labor force participation by Japanese women
differs from women in other developed nations as is made
clear by the well-known m-shaped curve with two peaks.
The number of women entering the work force peaks in the
20-24 age group, then gradually curves down during child
rearing years and has a second peak in the 45-49 age
group when women re enter the work force mainly as part
time workers. But recently we see a favorable trend in
which the curve is growing steadily to the right and is
less peaked.
Many women would like to continue working during
child bearing years, but the cultural belief that men
should work outside and women should remain in the home
still persists. This means that women are entrusted with
the upbringing and education of children and feel
obliged to devote their entire effort and time to their
children until these children enter school.
There is also a lack of public and corporate
infrastructure to facilitate smoother relations between
workplace and home. For example, there are still
approximately 40,000 children waiting to get into
nursery schools, especially in urban areas. Furthermore,
Japanese corporate culture places priority on the
company, which means long working hours and after-hours
drinking with clients and colleagues. In addition, even
if their wives work husbands do little to help around
the house. Men whose wives work spend an average of 25
minutes a day helping around the house, compared to 4
hours and 12 minutes of household work put in by working
women.
Despite the barriers and obstacles in their way,
women are making slow and steady progress. And despite
the fact that the world economic forum ranked Japan 69
out of 75 as far as empowerment of women is concerned, I
feel that we are definitely making some progress, slowly
but surely. I would just like to run through a few
figures that indicate women's participation in certain
fields.
Women in Government Japan's best and
brightest university graduates still aspire to
government jobs, and it was recently reported in the
media that the number of women hired as fast track
bureaucrats for fiscal 2004 was a record 124, or 19% of
the new recruits. In the international realm, the first
woman ambassador was appointed in 1980, and since then
we have had eleven women ambassadors. Today there are
three: the ambassadors to Italy, Ghana and the
disarmament mission in Geneva. Women have made the
biggest gains on government advisory councils and
panels. When I was first appointed to a panel about ten
years ago, only 10% of the members of all national
councils were women. Today that number has risen to
25%.
Women in Business As far as business is
concerned, women traditionally were hired by large
companies to serve in mostly auxiliary clerical roles
and to serve tea. Such women are widely referred to as
"OLs" or office ladies. However, since the equal
employment opportunity laws went into effect in 1986,
companies began to offer a two-track system to women.
One track allows them to continue in clerical work,
therefore avoiding excessive overtime and transfers to
other locations, and a career track has the same
obligations and opportunities as men. Regardless, only
9% of women have reached management positions.
So the more ambitious of these women who were getting
tired of bumping their heads against the bamboo ceiling
have decided to run their own businesses. We number
about 65,000 and represent 5% of the companies in Japan.
Most female entrepreneurs run small companies, where the
flexibility may allow them to continue to care for their
families. But the economic impact is significant and
will continue to grow.
About ten years ago a few women friends got together
and decided that we had to do something ourselves to
improve the status of women. Instead of waiting for
things to change, we decided that we would be catalysts
of change. We formed a group called leadership 111, made
up of women who had reached high levels in their
professions. Our objectives were to network among
ourselves and to learn from each other. We also decided
to help and encourage the next generation of women
leaders by holding seminars and programs. Our name,
leadership 111, is a play on the words "wan wan",
Japanese for how dog bark. We are determined to bark
loudly and clearly to make ourselves heard. Leadership
111 with one extra bark. We now count among our members
three present and former cabinet ministers, a couple of
former ambassadors, a governor and many successful
businesswomen, scientists and educators. We are also
trying to expand our network internationally and have
visited our counterparts in various countries. I am
hoping that my visit to Quebec will be a seed that will
grow into a strong relationship between the women
leaders of Canada and the women leaders of
Japan.
Women in Politics As far as politics is
concerned, female representation in the diet or
parliament is among the lowest in the world. Including
both chambers it is about 10%. In 1946 the new
constitution after the war gave women the right to vote
for the first time, and in the House of Representatives
election that year 39 women were elected. We have never
been able to regain such numbers. Therefore, not being
able to just sit by and do nothing, about six or seven
years ago five of my friends got together and decided
that in order to speed up the process of improving the
status of women we would need to increase the number of
talented and proactive women politicians. We formed a
group called "Win Win" because we felt that if we could
increase the number of women in government it would be a
win for us and it would be a win for the country. We
have since greatly increased our membership, which of
course also includes men.
In Japan, where approximately 40% of the members of
parliament are second or third generation politicians,
it is difficult for newcomers to break in. for example,
Prime Minister Koizumi's father and grandfather were
politicians. They say that in order to win one needs
kanban, kaban and jiban. These Japanese words translated
into name recognition, a bag of money and a
constituency. Most of the women that we are supporting
don't have any of those requirements, so we try at least
to supply the money. WinWin is a fundraising
organization, but our members also help out by giving
campaign speeches and do other support work. We have
helped to elect 17 women to both houses of the diet, and
in the recent lower house elections five of the 10 women
we supported won.
But we feel that we have made the biggest strides in
local government. Until the year 2000 we had no women
governors, and now only three years later there are four
out of 47 and they are heading fairly important
prefectures: Hokkaido, Osaka, Chiba and
Kumamoto.
Individualism and Cultural Exchange The
last social change that I would like to discuss is the
diversifying lifestyle of the Japanese people. Japan
used to be a country of monolithic culture and uniform
tastes. There is a saying, "minna de watareba
kowakunai", which translates as "if we all cross
together we have no fear". People of old Japan took
comfort in looking and acting in the same manner and not
sticking out. Now people are aspiring to different
dreams. Just visit Harajuku on a weekend and you will
see throngs of young people, teenagers dressed as
individualistically as they can. Boys and girls wearing
purple or green wigs, in any kind of outlandish dress
possible. This is the generation of children born after
Japan had gained recognition as a global economic power.
They are confident in themselves and they are confident
in their fashion sense, and not only easily adopt
western culture as their own but add their own
individual flair and interpretation. This is the
generation of Japanese that is helping to bring about a
new type of leadership being referred as to GNC or
"gross national cool", as opposed to the GDP equated
with the now waning economic leadership. And, indeed,
Japan is exporting its new culture of cool throughout
the world.
Japanese music is recognized throughout Asia.
Japanese animated films such as Spirited Away have
captivated audiences around the world, and Japanese pop
artist Takashi Murakami has combined the best of both
worlds by decorating Louis Vuitton bags with his cute
characters. Hello Kitty is almost as popular as Mickey
Mouse. Furthermore, in a show of so called soft power,
designers such as Yamamoto Kansai and Kenzo have been
dressing elegant women around the world for years. In
addition, Japanese culinary art has risen to new highs
globally. A generation ago Japanese cuisine was almost
unknown outside of the country, but now it is found
everywhere. I am told that sushi is an extremely popular
dish in Quebec.
Lifestyles are also diversifying for people in their
twenties and thirties. Due to the economic impact of
globalization, employers are being forced to modify
their employment contracts as it becomes more difficult
to maintain the Japanese style of labor management.
However, an Anglo Saxon style of management cannot be
imported as is, so Japanese companies are finding some
midway solutions.
In other words, life long employment will continue to
be guaranteed more or less for full time employees, but
companies will be hiring less full time employees and
salaries and promotion based on the seniority system are
starting to give way to performance based
remuneration.
In place of full time employees, companies are hiring
more contract workers, part time workers and "freeters"
(freeter is a new Japanese expression taken from the
English "free" and the German "arbeiter" or worker. Free
worker, in other words not tied down to one company). So
as a consequence of hard economic times and often out of
choice, young men and women are enjoying a freer work
environment. As a matter of fact we also are beginning
to see full time employees job-hop. People are aspiring
to different dreams.
Many single working men and women opt to live with
their parents despite their financial independence, and
because they usually only contribute a small percentage
of their incomes to their parents they can afford a very
affluent life style. They are extremely brand conscious
and fashionable. Therefore despite the recession, Louis
Vuitton, Prada and Gucci are extremely successful in
Japan.
Changes for Middle-Aged Citizens and
Seniors Moving on to changes in the life styles
of the middle aged and older people, Japan is referred
to as a job-linked society and the focus of salaried
men's relationships are workplace oriented. When these
salaried men retire this can result in two different
social trends.
The first is that middle-aged wives who had been left
alone while their husbands worked long hours and spent
weekends on company-related activities had to find their
own hobbies and friends. But when their husbands retire
with no real friends of their own and no hobbies, these
husbands try to find a place in their wives' lives but
are considered a nuisance. Such husbands are called
"nureochiba" or wet leaves because they are difficult to
sweep away, or even "sodai gomi" or big rubbish. One
result is that when children are grown there is no need
for women in such relationships to keep up the facade
any longer, so they get divorced and enjoy going out to
eat and traveling with women friends.
The second trend is more positive: the increasing
popularity of volunteer activities among the middle aged
and retired as a way not only of doing good for the
community but also to form friendships with other people
of similar interests.
Conclusion In conclusion, from a
businessperson's view these social changes also present
new opportunities. The decreasing number of children
means that parents and grandparents are willing to spend
more money on each child. It is not unusual to see
children dressed in designer clothes or with a TV set in
their own rooms. The aging population opens up business
challenges and opportunities in providing nursing care,
but also goods and services for an age group with a
fairly large amount of disposable income. Finally, the
increasing entry of women into the work force presents
opportunities in private day care centers and other
services catering to working women.
As Japan leads the world in confronting a diminishing
and aging population, its people look to political
leadership to make the right decisions and assure the
security and safety and well being of the nation. Will
they succeed? Only time will tell, and we don't have too
much time left. |